Compare Flat Rate vs. Calculated Shipping Profitability
Original cost of item + packaging materials
Enter 0 for Free Shipping
Includes shipping fee percentage (usually ~13.25%)
Estimated Carrier Costs (What you pay to ship):
Profit Comparison
Scenario
Nearby Buyer (Zone 1)
Mid Buyer (Zone 5)
Far Buyer (Zone 8)
Flat Rate ($0.00) Total Profit
–
–
–
Calculated Shipping Total Profit
–
–
–
Shipping Variance Gain/Loss on Ship Cost only (Flat Rate)
–
–
–
Should You Use Calculated or Flat Rate Shipping on eBay?
Choosing the right shipping strategy is crucial for maintaining margins and attracting buyers. This calculator helps you compare the profitability of using a Fixed Flat Rate versus eBay's Calculated Shipping based on buyer location.
Definitions
Calculated Shipping: The buyer pays the exact cost (or a negotiated rate) based on the package's weight, dimensions, and the distance to their address. This protects your profit margins on cross-country shipments.
Flat Rate Shipping: You charge a single fee to all buyers, regardless of location. This is simpler for buyers to understand but carries the risk of undercharging for distant zones (Zones 8-9).
Free Shipping: Effectively a "Flat Rate" of $0.00. You must build the average shipping cost into your item price.
How to Read the Results
The Shipping Variance row shows exactly how much you make or lose strictly on the shipping transaction when using a Flat Rate.
If Variance is Positive: Your Flat Rate is higher than the actual cost. You are keeping the difference (offsetting fees).
If Variance is Negative: Your Flat Rate is too low. You are subsidizing the shipping out of your item's profit.
When to Use Each Strategy
Use Flat Rate (or Free Shipping) when:
The item fits in a USPS Flat Rate Box (Small, Medium, or Large).
The item is under 1 lb (First Class/Ground Advantage costs don't vary wildly).
You want to boost search ranking (Free Shipping is a search filter).
Use Calculated Shipping when:
The item is heavy (over 2-3 lbs) or bulky.
The difference between Zone 1 and Zone 8 shipping costs is significant (e.g., $10 vs $45).
You ship internationally via eBay International Shipping.
function calculateShippingStrategy() {
// 1. Get Inputs
var itemPrice = parseFloat(document.getElementById('itemPrice').value);
var itemCost = parseFloat(document.getElementById('itemCost').value);
var flatRate = parseFloat(document.getElementById('proposedFlatRate').value);
var feeRate = parseFloat(document.getElementById('ebayFeeRate').value);
var costLocal = parseFloat(document.getElementById('costZoneLocal').value);
var costMid = parseFloat(document.getElementById('costZoneMid').value);
var costFar = parseFloat(document.getElementById('costZoneFar').value);
// 2. Validation
if (isNaN(itemPrice) || isNaN(itemCost) || isNaN(flatRate) || isNaN(costLocal) || isNaN(costMid) || isNaN(costFar)) {
alert("Please fill in all fields with valid numbers.");
return;
}
// 3. Logic – Helper function for Profit Calculation
function calculateNetProfit(price, shippingCharged, actualShippingCost, cogs, feePercent) {
var totalRevenue = price + shippingCharged;
var totalFees = totalRevenue * (feePercent / 100);
var net = totalRevenue – totalFees – actualShippingCost – cogs;
return net;
}
// 4. Calculate Scenario A: Flat Rate Strategy
var flatProfitLocal = calculateNetProfit(itemPrice, flatRate, costLocal, itemCost, feeRate);
var flatProfitMid = calculateNetProfit(itemPrice, flatRate, costMid, itemCost, feeRate);
var flatProfitFar = calculateNetProfit(itemPrice, flatRate, costFar, itemCost, feeRate);
// 5. Calculate Scenario B: Calculated Shipping Strategy
// Assumption: In calculated shipping, you charge the buyer exactly what it costs you (or close to it).
// So Shipping Charged = Actual Shipping Cost.
var calcProfitLocal = calculateNetProfit(itemPrice, costLocal, costLocal, itemCost, feeRate);
var calcProfitMid = calculateNetProfit(itemPrice, costMid, costMid, itemCost, feeRate);
var calcProfitFar = calculateNetProfit(itemPrice, costFar, costFar, itemCost, feeRate);
// 6. Calculate Shipping Variance (Flat Rate vs Actual Cost)
// This is purely: (Flat Rate Charged) – (Actual Cost)
// Note: This doesn't account for fees on shipping, just raw shipping wallet impact.
var varLocal = flatRate – costLocal;
var varMid = flatRate – costMid;
var varFar = flatRate – costFar;
// 7. Update DOM
document.getElementById('displayFlatRate').innerText = flatRate.toFixed(2);
updateResultCell('flatProfitLocal', flatProfitLocal);
updateResultCell('flatProfitMid', flatProfitMid);
updateResultCell('flatProfitFar', flatProfitFar);
updateResultCell('calcProfitLocal', calcProfitLocal);
updateResultCell('calcProfitMid', calcProfitMid);
updateResultCell('calcProfitFar', calcProfitFar);
updateResultCell('shipVarLocal', varLocal);
updateResultCell('shipVarMid', varMid);
updateResultCell('shipVarFar', varFar);
// 8. Generate Advice
var adviceDiv = document.getElementById('strategyAdvice');
var adviceHTML = "";
if (flatProfitFar < 0) {
adviceHTML += "Warning: You are losing money on Zone 8 (Cross Country) sales with this Flat Rate. Consider increasing your Flat Rate or switching to Calculated Shipping.";
} else if (flatProfitFar < calcProfitFar) {
adviceHTML += "Observation: You make less profit on distant sales with Flat Rate compared to Calculated, but you are still profitable.";
}
if (varLocal > 0 && varFar < 0) {
adviceHTML += "Strategy Check: Your Flat Rate overcharges local buyers and undercharges distant buyers. This is normal for Flat Rate, but ensure the average balances out.";
}
if (flatRate === 0) {
adviceHTML += "Free Shipping Mode: Ensure your Item Price ($" + itemPrice.toFixed(2) + ") is high enough to cover the Zone 8 shipping cost ($" + costFar.toFixed(2) + ") plus fees.";
}
adviceDiv.innerHTML = adviceHTML;
document.getElementById('resultsArea').style.display = 'block';
}
function updateResultCell(elementId, value) {
var el = document.getElementById(elementId);
el.innerText = "$" + value.toFixed(2);
if (value >= 0) {
el.className = "profit-positive";
} else {
el.className = "profit-negative";
}
}