In Calculating the Unemployment Rate Discouraged Workers Are

by

Impact of Discouraged Workers on Unemployment Rate Calculator

This calculator demonstrates how including "discouraged workers" affects unemployment statistics. It compares a standard rate (similar to U-3) against an alternative rate (similar to U-4) that includes these specific individuals.

People currently holding jobs.
People without jobs who are actively looking for work.
People who want jobs but stopped looking because they believe no work is available for them.
function calculateLaborRates() { // 1. Get input values var employedStr = document.getElementById('employedCount').value; var unemployedStr = document.getElementById('unemployedCount').value; var discouragedStr = document.getElementById('discouragedCount').value; // 2. Parse values to numbers (ensure non-negative) var employed = Math.abs(parseFloat(employedStr)); var unemployed = Math.abs(parseFloat(unemployedStr)); var discouraged = Math.abs(parseFloat(discouragedStr)); var resultDiv = document.getElementById('resultOutput'); resultDiv.style.display = 'block'; // 3. Validation for invalid inputs if (isNaN(employed) || isNaN(unemployed) || isNaN(discouraged)) { resultDiv.innerHTML = 'Please enter valid numeric values for all fields.'; return; } // 4. Core Calculations // Standard Labor Force = Employed + Unemployed (actively looking) var standardLaborForce = employed + unemployed; // Standard Rate (U-3 equivalent) = (Unemployed / Standard Labor Force) var standardRate = 0; if (standardLaborForce > 0) { standardRate = (unemployed / standardLaborForce) * 100; } // Expanded Labor Force = Standard Labor Force + Discouraged Workers // When calculating alternative rates, discouraged workers are added back into the labor force pool. var expandedLaborForce = standardLaborForce + discouraged; var totalExpandedUnemployed = unemployed + discouraged; // Alternative Rate (U-4 equivalent) = ((Unemployed + Discouraged) / Expanded Labor Force) var alternativeRate = 0; if (expandedLaborForce > 0) { alternativeRate = (totalExpandedUnemployed / expandedLaborForce) * 100; } var rateDifference = alternativeRate – standardRate; // 5. Display Results var resultHtml = '

Calculation Results

'; resultHtml += '
'; resultHtml += '
'; resultHtml += 'Standard Rate (Excluding Discouraged)'; resultHtml += 'Standard Labor Force: ' + standardLaborForce.toLocaleString() + "; resultHtml += 'Unemployment Rate: ' + standardRate.toFixed(2) + '%'; resultHtml += '
'; resultHtml += '
'; resultHtml += 'Alternative Rate (Including Discouraged)'; resultHtml += 'Expanded Labor Force: ' + expandedLaborForce.toLocaleString() + "; resultHtml += 'Alternative Rate: ' + alternativeRate.toFixed(2) + '%'; resultHtml += '
'; resultHtml += '
'; resultHtml += 'Adding discouraged workers increased the calculated unemployment rate by ' + rateDifference.toFixed(2) + ' percentage points.'; resultDiv.innerHTML = resultHtml; }

Understanding Discouraged Workers in Unemployment Calculations

When analyzing economic health, the headline unemployment rate often tells only part of the story. A critical nuance lies in understanding that in calculating the standard unemployment rate, discouraged workers are typically excluded from the labor force entirely. This exclusion can sometimes paint a rosier picture of the job market than reality reflects.

Who Are Discouraged Workers?

Discouraged workers are a specific subset of the "marginally attached" workforce. According to standard definitions used by organizations like the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), these are individuals who are not currently employed, want a job, are available to work, and have looked for work sometime in the past 12 months. However, they are not counted as actively unemployed because they have not specifically looked for work in the last 4 weeks.

The defining characteristic is why they stopped looking. They are "discouraged" because they believe no jobs are available for them due to economic conditions or personal factors (such as age, schooling, or lacking skills).

Why Are They Excluded from Standard Rates?

The standard unemployment rate (known as U-3 in the United States) requires an individual to be actively seeking employment to be counted as part of the "labor force." The labor force is the denominator in the primary calculation equation:

Standard Rate = (Actively Unemployed / (Employed + Actively Unemployed)) * 100

Because discouraged workers have stopped actively looking, statistical agencies classify them as "not in the labor force." Therefore, they do not appear in either the numerator or the denominator of the standard rate calculation.

How Including Them Changes the Data

To get a broader measure of labor underutilization, economists use alternative measures (like U-4, U-5, or U-6). When discouraged workers are added back into the equation, they must be added to both the count of unemployed persons (the numerator) and the total size of the labor force (the denominator).

A Realistic Example:

Let's assume a hypothetical economy has the following numbers:

  • Employed: 10,000,000 people
  • Actively Unemployed: 500,000 people
  • Discouraged Workers: 200,000 people

Standard Calculation (Excluding Discouraged):
The Labor Force is 10.5 million (10M employed + 0.5M unemployed). The rate is (500,000 / 10,500,000) = 4.76%.

Alternative Calculation (Including Discouraged):
We add the 200,000 discouraged workers to the unemployed pool (making it 700,000) AND add them to the total labor force (making it 10.7 million). The new rate is (700,000 / 10,700,000) = 6.54%.

As shown in this example and the calculator above, including discouraged workers almost invariably results in a higher unemployment rate, offering a distinct perspective on hidden slack in the labor market.

Leave a Comment