Incremental Rate of Return Calculator

by

Incremental Rate of Return (ROR) Calculator

This calculator helps evaluate the financial viability of choosing a higher-cost investment option over a lower-cost alternative. It calculates the rate of return specifically on the additional capital invested.

Option A (Base/Lower Cost)

Option B (Alternative/Higher Cost)

Results will appear here…
function calculateIncrementalROR() { var costA = parseFloat(document.getElementById('costA').value); var flowA = parseFloat(document.getElementById('flowA').value); var costB = parseFloat(document.getElementById('costB').value); var flowB = parseFloat(document.getElementById('flowB').value); var resultDiv = document.getElementById('rorResult'); if (isNaN(costA) || isNaN(flowA) || isNaN(costB) || isNaN(flowB)) { resultDiv.innerHTML = 'Please enter valid numeric values for all investment and cash flow fields.'; return; } if (costA < 0 || flowA < 0 || costB < 0 || flowB < 0) { resultDiv.innerHTML = 'Values should generally be positive numbers for this analysis.'; return; } // Ensure Option B is the higher cost option for standard incremental analysis logic if (costB <= costA) { resultDiv.innerHTML = 'To calculate an Incremental ROR, Option B must have a higher initial investment than Option A. Please ensure Option B is the more expensive alternative.'; return; } var incrementalCost = costB – costA; var incrementalFlow = flowB – flowA; // Avoid division by zero, though the costB > costA check above handles this. if (incrementalCost === 0) { resultDiv.innerHTML = 'Incremental cost cannot be zero.'; return; } // Simple annual incremental ROR calculation var incrementalROR = (incrementalFlow / incrementalCost) * 100; var outputHTML = 'Analysis of Additional Investment:'; outputHTML += '
    '; outputHTML += '
  • Extra Capital Invested: ' + incrementalCost.toFixed(2) + '
    • '; outputHTML += '
  • Extra Annual Cash Flow Gained: ' + incrementalFlow.toFixed(2) + '
    • '; outputHTML += '
'; outputHTML += 'Incremental Rate of Return: ' + incrementalROR.toFixed(2) + '%'; if (incrementalFlow <= 0) { outputHTML += 'Warning: The more expensive option does not generate higher annual cash flows. The incremental investment may not be justified.'; } resultDiv.innerHTML = outputHTML; }

Understanding Incremental Rate of Return Analysis

Incremental Rate of Return (ROR) analysis is a critical capital budgeting tool used when deciding between two mutually exclusive investment opportunities. It answers a specific question: "Is the extra money spent on the more expensive option earning a sufficient return?"

Instead of looking at the total return of each project individually, incremental analysis focuses entirely on the differences between them. It compares the additional investment required to upgrade from a base option (Option A) to a more expensive alternative (Option B) against the additional cash flows that alternative generates.

How to Interpret the Result

The calculated Incremental ROR represents the return percentage specifically on the extra capital invested in Option B. To make a decision, compare this result to your company's Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) or hurdle rate.

  • If Incremental ROR > MARR: The additional investment in the more expensive option (Option B) is justified because the extra cost earns more than your required threshold.
  • If Incremental ROR < MARR: The additional investment is not justified. You should stick with the lower-cost base option (Option A), as the extra money spent is not generating enough return.

Example Scenario

Imagine a manufacturing company choosing between two machines:

  • Machine A (Base): Costs 50,000 and generates 10,000 annually in savings.
  • Machine B (Alternative): Costs 80,000 and generates 16,000 annually in savings.

The incremental cost is 30,000 (80k – 50k). The incremental annual cash flow is 6,000 (16k – 10k).

The Incremental ROR is (6,000 / 30,000) = 20%. If the company's hurdle rate is 15%, they should choose Machine B, as the extra 30,000 invested earns a healthy 20% return.

Note: This calculator uses a simplified annual return method suitable for comparing projects with similar lifespans and constant cash flows. For complex scenarios involving varying cash flows over time, a full Incremental Internal Rate of Return (IRR) analysis using discounted cash flows is recommended.

Leave a Comment